Someone asks how you’re doing. You pause for a moment, almost imperceptibly, and then say, “I’m fine.” You might even smile. You might even be fine—in a functional, productive, responsible kind of way. I know this place well. The subtle dissonance between what’s happening inside and what I present on the outside. The part of me that grew up learning to be composed, resilient, and insightful—while hiding the messier parts underneath. Not because I’m being fake. But because I’ve learned, like so many of us, that not everyone can hold the parts of us that aren’t “fine.” Psychoanalyst D.W. Winnicott called this the false self—the version of ourselves we put forward in order to stay safe, accepted, or in control. It’s not a lie exactly. It’s just… incomplete. It’s a survival strategy that says: Don’t need too much. Don’t break the rules. Don’t risk being a burden. But the cost? You begin to disappear from your own life. Over time, you may notice a low-level restlessness. A kind of spiritual or emotional anemia. You keep showing up for others, doing what you’re supposed to do, being who you’re supposed to be—but something in you is growing quietly angry, hungry, or sad. Therapy often begins at this exact point—when the old strategies stop working, or when the emotional void becomes too painful to ignore. We talk. We explore. And slowly, you learn to listen to the parts of you that have been whispering under the surface. Here’s what I’ve learned: “I’m fine” is sometimes code for “I’ve left the building.” It means I’ve gone into self-sufficiency mode. I’ve tucked my heart behind a smile. I’ve chosen safety over realness. But realness is where the healing happens. So I’ll ask you now, as I ask myself (often): What part of you goes quiet when you say, “I’m fine”? And what would happen if you let it speak? |
Mirel Goldstein, MS, MA, LPC is an award-winning, licensed therapist with 20+ years of clinical experience and is a published author.
When Your Defenses Become Your Personality Sometimes the traits we learned early in life to survive — being “nice,” “strong,” “funny,” “independent” — become the very things people love and expect from us. We get praised for them. Rewarded for them. Identified with them. But what if they aren’t just natural parts of who we are? What if once upon a time these traits were defenses — ways to cope, adapt, and stay safe in a world that didn’t always give us what we needed or meet us where we were...
Here are some links to my recent blog posts for those of you who haven't seen them posted elsewhere (the newsletter content in contrast to my blog posts is exclusive for you subscribers!) Whose Desire are You Carrying: https://goldsteintherapy.com/whose-desire-are-you-carrying/ How Therapy Can Detoxify Shame: https://goldsteintherapy.com/how-therapy-can-detoxify-shame/ Why Giving Love Can Feel Harder Than Receiving It:...
Let’s talk about something that doesn’t get said enough:When closeness feels too scary, we don’t push people away to be mean. We do it to survive. To feel safe. To stay in control. We tell ourselves we’re “independent,” or that we “don’t need anyone,” but beneath all that distance? There’s often a much younger part of us saying: “Please don’t hurt me like that again.” Because sometimes, connection hasn’t felt safe. Maybe love came with conditions. Maybe it disappeared when you needed it most....